Senate Republicans race to confirm Trump's judges before Democrats take control
With Democrats set to take the Senate majority in January, Republicans are speeding President Trump's judicial nominees toward confirmation, including two Texas picks that bypassed the state's usual vetting process.
Senate Republicans are moving through a backlog of President Trump's judicial nominees at an accelerated pace in the final weeks before Democrats take control of the chamber, scheduling back-to-back confirmation hearings and advancing at least two picks for Texas seats who bypass the home-state screening process the state's senators have used for nearly every prior nominee.
The push follows the Nov. 3 midterm elections, in which Republicans lost the Senate majority they had used for nearly two years to confirm federal judges with little Democratic input. Democrats are projected to hold at least 54 seats when the new Congress convenes on Jan. 3, 2027, with a final count of up to 56 depending on outstanding tabulations in Mississippi and Alaska. Until then, the outgoing Republican majority retains the votes to confirm anyone President Trump sends to the floor, and party leaders are racing to use what time is left.
By the numbers
The federal judiciary's own vacancy tracker listed 27 open Article III judgeships as of Nov. 15, with nominees already pending for 10 of them. A week earlier, Reuters put the number of current and imminent vacancies at 43, counting seats expected to open in the coming weeks and months, and reported that nine nominations were awaiting action in the Senate Judiciary Committee while 13 others had already cleared committee and could reach the floor before Christmas. Four of the pending nominees are for seats on intermediate appeals courts, which Republicans consider the highest priority given how rarely circuit vacancies arise.
The committee has not slowed down to accommodate the transition. It held a nomination hearing on Nov. 10 covering five picks, including Todd Butler, a Phelps Dunbar partner nominated to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, and three district court nominees for Tennessee, North Dakota and Louisiana. A second hearing is already on the calendar for Nov. 18, a schedule that breaks from the committee's customary every-other-week pace. Since Trump returned to office, the Senate has confirmed more than 55 lifetime judges, on top of the 234 he appointed during his first term.
Bypassing the usual screening
The clearest sign of the time pressure is in Texas, where two district court seats are being filled with nominees who did not go through the Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee, the vetting panel Sens. John Cornyn and Ted Cruz have used for nearly every judicial recommendation they have sent the White House. Elliot Gaiser, an assistant attorney general who leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel and clerked on the Fifth Circuit nearly a decade ago, was put forward for the Northern District of Texas. James Sullivan, a sitting Texas Supreme Court justice who lost his bid for reelection to that court the week before, was nominated to the Western District of Texas. Neither has significant residency or practice ties to the specific federal district to which he was nominated beyond that earlier clerkship or statewide service.
Cornyn, who is leaving the Senate in January after losing his own reelection race, told reporters he learned of Gaiser's nomination only after the paperwork had already reached the Judiciary Committee.
"The White House is doing this even after Senator Cruz and I sent them a number of well-qualified nominees that they could have sent down here and avoided this, but that's not what they chose to do," Cornyn told reporters, adding of Gaiser specifically: "I'll look at his record and make a decision, but this is not the usual process."
Legal scholars following the nominations said the appeal of the Northern District, in particular, is straightforward. Paul Gugliuzza, a University of Texas at Austin law professor, noted that every active judge on that court was appointed by a Republican president and that its case-assignment rules in some divisions let litigants know in advance which judge will hear a dispute, a point that has made the district a favored venue for challenges to federal regulations.
Democrats object, and some conservatives are uneasy too
Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois, the Judiciary Committee's outgoing ranking Democrat, has argued that Republicans are breaking with longstanding practice to install nominees loyal to the president before losing the ability to do so, pointing specifically to Sullivan's and Gaiser's thin ties to the districts they would serve. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, expected to take the committee's gavel when Democrats assume the majority, has gone further, framing the compressed hearing schedule as part of a broader erosion of the panel's oversight function under Republican control.
Rachel Rossi, president of the progressive Alliance for Justice, said Democrats should treat any nominee who will not acknowledge that Trump lost the 2020 election, or who has downplayed the Jan. 6, 2021 attack on the Capitol, as presumptively unfit regardless of how quickly Republicans try to move them through.
The criticism is not confined to one side. Ed Whelan, a prominent conservative legal commentator and former law clerk to the late Justice Antonin Scalia, has warned that Trump's handling of the process, including public pressure on Senate leaders and reported interest in retirements from the Supreme Court's two oldest conservatives, risks squandering the party's most durable achievement of the last decade: a reshaped federal judiciary. Justices Clarence Thomas, 78, and Samuel Alito, 76, have both indicated in recent interviews that they intend to keep serving, making a lame-duck Supreme Court vacancy unlikely.
Robert Luther III, a George Mason University law professor who worked on judicial selection in the White House Counsel's Office during Trump's first term, said he expects nearly every pending nominee to be confirmed before January regardless of the objections, but predicted confirmations would slow "to a trickle" once Democrats control the floor schedule. Carl Tobias, a University of Richmond law professor who tracks the federal bench, said he anticipates considerable Democratic resistance once the majority changes hands, particularly toward nominees confirmed in the lame-duck session itself.
The current pace still falls well short of what Republicans managed under full control. By comparison, during the last two years of Barack Obama's presidency, when Republicans held the Senate, only about 20 of his district and circuit court nominees were confirmed, and Merrick Garland's Supreme Court nomination never received a hearing or a vote at all.
What comes next
The Judiciary Committee's Nov. 18 hearing is expected to be followed by additional executive business meetings to formally advance nominees to the floor, where Majority Leader John Thune has signaled judicial confirmations will take precedence over most other business before the new Congress convenes. That timeline is complicated by an overlapping deadline: government funding lapses Dec. 11 unless Congress passes new appropriations or another stopgap, competing for floor time with the nominations push in the same compressed window.
Underlying the urgency is a fight Republicans have so far avoided having directly: Trump has repeatedly pressed Thune and Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley to eliminate blue slips, the century-old practice letting home-state senators block district court and U.S. attorney nominees, arguing it has slowed his picks. Both men have refused, with Thune saying opposition to scrapping the custom runs deeper among Senate Republicans than opposition to ending the legislative filibuster. That refusal has not stopped the administration from moving forward on the Texas seats without the state's own vetting process, a workaround that does not require touching the blue-slip rule itself.
Once Democrats take the majority on Jan. 3, Whitehouse has signaled he intends what he has called a "hard reset" on the nominations process, a shift that is expected to all but halt confirmations to the appeals courts and make any Supreme Court nomination from Trump a practical impossibility for the remainder of his term. For now, the outgoing majority is working through what calendar it has left, and Cornyn's seat is likely to be one of the clearer markers of how that time was used once the Senate changes hands.
Democrat edges out House Rules Committee chair in tight North Carolina recount race

White House warns incoming Democratic Congress that oversight could cross into 'blatant criminality'
