US Edition
Your source for latest news
OpinionOpinion

Opinion: The UN's climate summits keep rewarding the wrong hosts

A mass climate march swept through Antalya this weekend under heavy policing, exposing how the UN's climate process has quietly rebuilt the authoritarian hosting playbook it should have retired after Dubai and Baku.

PN
By PressTemps NewsroomPublished Yesterday, 01:11 ET · 6 min read
Opinion: The UN's climate summits keep rewarding the wrong hosts
File photo: Antalya, Türkiye, the host city of the COP31 climate summit, seen against the snow-capped Taurus Mountains. Photo: Sharon Hahn Darlin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0
What to know
COP31's host country agreement with Türkiye reinstates a clause requiring participants not to "interfere" in Türkiye's internal affairs; the same clause was in COP28 (UAE) and COP29 (Azerbaijan) deals but was dropped for COP30 in Brazil.
Human Rights Watch documented Turkish authorities detaining and prosecuting environmental protesters, including activist Esra Işık (42 days detained, later sentenced to two years and one month) and 225 people arrested before July's Ankara NATO summit.
A march of thousands through Antalya on November 14, 2026 (COP31's midpoint) demanded climate finance and a fossil-fuel phase-out, with marchers searched by police before joining; negotiations run through November 20 with no major breakthrough expected.
Civil society groups have criticized the draft Just Transition Mechanism as toothless, and African governments and rich nations remain divided over a proposed tripling of adaptation finance to $120 billion a year by 2035.

On Saturday, in a cold rain, thousands of campaigners marched through central Antalya chanting a line borrowed from Greta Thunberg's old taunt to power: "No more blah blah blah — climate justice now." The demonstration, described by organizers and reporters on the ground as the largest since the summit began, marked the midpoint of the 31st UN Climate Change Conference, which runs through November 20 at the Antalya Expo Center. The march itself went off without major incident. What makes it worth dwelling on is the government that policed it: the same authorities who, by Human Rights Watch's documented count, have spent the past three years tear-gassing, fining and prosecuting their own environmental protesters.

That contradiction, more than any single finance dispute inside the negotiating halls, is the real story of COP31's halfway point. It is also a symptom of something the United Nations has let fester through three consecutive climate summits: a habit of handing the hosting of the world's most important forum on civil action to governments actively hostile to civil action at home. The UN should stop treating that as an awkward footnote and start treating it as a disqualifying condition.

A pattern dressed up as an exception

Türkiye's agreement to host COP31 includes a clause obliging accredited participants not to "interfere" in the country's internal affairs — language that grants delegates legal immunity for what they say or do at the summit only on a case-by-case basis, coordinated with Turkish authorities. According to reporting on the signed host country agreement, the same clause appeared in the hosting deals for COP28 in the United Arab Emirates and COP29 in Azerbaijan, was deliberately dropped for COP30 in Brazil, and has now been reintroduced for Antalya. Amnesty International's climate justice policy adviser, Ann Harrison, called its return "extremely disappointing," warning it could produce a "wider chilling effect" on free expression and assembly at the one annual gathering built around the premise that ordinary people's voices should count.

This is not a one-off lapse. It is a toggle switch the UN system keeps flipping back to whenever a government with a thin tolerance for dissent wins the hosting rights, and then flipping off again when a more open society takes its turn.

Supporters of this year's arrangement point to a genuine structural innovation: Türkiye, whose environment minister and COP31 president, Murat Kurum, told the UN secretariat and states parties he intended to run an inclusive, implementation-focused summit, handles logistics and the "action agenda," while Australia's climate minister, Chris Bowen, chairs the formal negotiations as president — a split confirmed by the UN's own COP31 page and one Bowen has called a model worth repeating. It is a reasonable idea. But it does not touch the parts of hosting that most affect civil society: accreditation, venue security, and the internal-affairs clause itself all still run through Ankara, not Canberra.

What the crackdown actually looks like

The Human Rights Watch accounting is specific. Environmental campaigner Esra Işık was held for 42 days after an Akbelen protest in March and later convicted and sentenced to two years and one month for "resisting officials," a case now on appeal. Before July's NATO summit in Ankara, courts placed 178 people in pretrial detention among 225 ordered arrested, a group that included thirteen members of a nature conservation organization later released without charge. Fines for hanging protest banners or parking near demonstrations have run as high as 250,000 lira, more than $5,000.

"Türkiye's environmental crackdown is a salient reminder of its intolerance of dissent," said Deniz Bayram, the group's assistant Europe and Central Asia researcher, adding that the government has "turned on local people who are speaking out against environmental damage."

Amnesty International raised similar alarms before Türkiye's bid was finalized, with its climate justice program director, Marta Schaaf, urging Ankara to "respect, protect and facilitate the work of environmental human rights defenders" — a standard the government's own climate targets, rated "highly insufficient" against the Paris Agreement's goals, have done little to meet. Against that backdrop, Saturday's marchers moved through the city under close police supervision, searched before they could even join the rally. The summit's own organizers, in other words, built a system in which the people the conference exists to represent have to be screened to get near it.

The talks inside aren't faring much better

None of this would matter quite as much if the negotiating rooms were producing results commensurate with the moment. They are not. Civil society groups, including Oil Change International and the Fossil Fuel Treaty Initiative, have dismissed the draft Just Transition Mechanism on the table as "a just transition mechanism in name only," lacking any dedicated finance body. A separate fight over the Global Goal on Adaptation pits African governments, who want a tripling of adaptation finance to at least $120 billion a year by 2035, against wealthier delegations resisting a hard number. The European Union's lead negotiator, Wopke Hoekstra, has already ruled out fresh finance pledges, even as the European Commission's own briefing lists climate finance among its stated COP31 priorities. A handful of countries, including Mexico, South Korea and Switzerland, are meanwhile pushing to move the whole process to a biennial schedule — a change that would halve the number of moments like this one in which governments face public account.

UN climate chief Simon Stiell described the week's progress as "constructive," which is the word diplomats reach for when nothing has collapsed but nothing has moved, either. Tasneem Essop of the Climate Action Network put it more bluntly: rich countries are "taking one step forward, three steps backward" on finance.

What should follow

None of this is an argument that only spotless democracies should host UN conferences; no government fully meets that test, and insisting otherwise would hand wealthy states another excuse to dodge scrutiny of their own, much larger failures on emissions and finance. Nor is the Türkiye-Australia split a fraud — separating the presidency of negotiations from the host country is a real and defensible reform. But a reform that leaves accreditation, security and legal immunity entirely in the hands of whichever government wins the hosting bid is not a safeguard; it is a workaround that lets the UN claim progress on civil-society access while the substance of that access keeps shrinking.

The UNFCCC secretariat and its Bureau should write enforceable, monitorable protections for protest, press and advocacy directly into every future host country agreement, with an independent mechanism — not a case-by-case negotiation with the host's own security services — empowered to flag violations publicly during the summit itself, not in a report published months later. Candidate hosts for COP32 should be made to accept that condition before, not after, winning the bid. And inside the Antalya talks that still have six days to run, negotiators owe the marchers who got searched on their way to demand action an actual answer on adaptation finance and a just transition mechanism with real money attached — not another work programme civil society groups will rightly call useless.

More on this story

All Opinion